It’s the final countdoooown! Here it is folks, the last installment of The 101 Best Songs of the Aughts.
Thanks for all your comments and feedback. They’ve inspired me to keep going with a project that has proven to be incredibly time consuming and incredibly rewarding.
(To see the entire countdown, go here.)
5. “Jesus Walks” by Kanye West (2004)
Is Kanye West an arrogant jerk who doesn’t know when to shut the hell up? Yes. Is he also an exhilarating artist? Yes. Yes. Triple yes.
Just listen to the sound of “Jesus Walks.” He pauses the beat to make strangled gasps. He weaves a choir and a church soloist together with slashes of strings. He underscores throbbing bass beats with ominous chants. The track is insistent and alive, and it’s matched by lyrics that are wounded, passionate, and funny (“Regis/Jesus”).
West’s antics are distracting, but for his personality to truly overshadow his music, he’d have to dress up like a Girl Scout and stage a food fight in Ethiopia.
—
4. “Joey” by Sugarland (2008)
Jennifer Nettles has the perfect voice for “Joey’s” story. A woman mourns her boyfriend’s death in a car crash, wondering if she could’ve done something to stop it. She chastises herself for not taking his keys, for not going with him, for not being there as he lay dying. She chastises herself for falling in love. And then in the chorus, too choked with feeling to keep making sentences, she just says she’s sorry, sorry, sorry.
Nettles communicates that pain with evocative phrasing and paint-peeling wails. Bandmate Kristian Bush supports her with Springsteen-style rock. Meanwhile, the ghosts of every teen angel and leader of the pack give a thumbs up to Sugarland for keeping this particular songwriting tradition alive.
—
3. “Be Mine!” by Robyn (2005)
Remember back at #21 when I said that “Handle Me” came from tough-girl Robyn? Well, “Be Mine!” comes from heartbreak Robyn.
If you don’t know this song, then I recommend listening to it twice in a row. It takes that long for the insistent rhythm and the chanted chorus to really sink it. And then they’ll stay in your brain for days.
Also… keep an ear open for the spoken-word bridge, where Robyn describes an inconsequential moment that breaks her heart into six million pieces. We’ve all been wounded by a single word or fleeting expression.The tiniest shards of glass go deepest under the skin.
—
2. “No Children” by The Mountain Goats (2002)
A song with so much anger that it becomes funny and scary at the same time, “No Children” has been holding me by the lapel for years. Check the bottom of this essay for all the reasons I love it. And then go back to savoring those lyrics. And that raw, raw feeling.
—
1. “Not Ready to Make Nice” by Dixie Chicks (2006)
“Not Ready to Make Nice” is a great song, a superlative song. It’s musically exciting, especially during the bridge, when Natalie Maines’ voice soars over all those drums and violins. As always with the Chicks, the harmonies and musicianship are impeccable, and the lyrics are astute.
But there are 100 other superlative songs on this list. “Not Ready to Make Nice” is number one because it’s not only a great work of art, but also a bold political act.
In the wake of the anti-Obama tea party protests, and people toting guns to Obama’s speeches, and parents refusing to let their children hear Obama speak, it is embarrassing to remember that so many people were outraged when Natalie Maines said she was ashamed that George W. Bush was from Texas.
Back in 2003, however, when the war was just starting and the neocon culture was at its peak, there was no way a country artist could dis Dubya. Eddie Vedder could impale a Dubya mask on a microphone stand, but that was different. That was a liberal rock star preaching to the choir. But country music—and especially county radio—was a bastion for songs about unquestioning patriotism. It was a haven for conservative ideology. (It still is.)
So when Maines made her statement in front of a London crowd, she threw boiling water in the face of the industry that supported her. She had the right to do it, of course, and country radio and country fans had the right to react how they wanted. You can’t publicly express yourself without accepting the possibility that somebody won’t like it. (Nobody had the right to threaten Maines’ life, but I’ll get to that in a second.)
It’s important to remember, though, that Maines’ statement was an accidental flashpoint. She didn’t know it would unleash a shitstorm. On the other hand, “Not Ready to Make Nice,” the lead single off the Chicks’ first album after the controversy, is a carefully planned statement.
And that statement is, “Screw you, you so-called fans and so-called Americans. I’m not going to apologize for having an opinion, and you should be dog-damned ashamed for threatening to kill me and teaching your children to hate me because I said something you didn’t want to hear.”
That’s an act of artistic bravery. The Chicks defined their principles, stood their ground, and refused to pretend they were fine. Instead of making nice with the country music world—a world that probably would have taken them back, since by the time the song was released, Faith Hill and Tim McGraw were openly chastising Bush over the Katrina debacle—instead of making nice with that world, they decided to call it on the carpet. They railed against the very industry that made the famous and made them rich, all so they could say what they thought was right.
Even classic country rebels like Waylon Jennings and George Jones never rebuked their community. They got their status because they rebelled against the parts of America that their base ostensibly hated. They rejected societies that seemed to look down on the blue collar and/or Southern fans who drive country music’s revenue.
By slamming New York City or fancypants rich people, the classic country rebels told their audience what they wanted to hear. They suggested that simply by being working class or Southern, their listeners were outlaws.
That’s rebellious in a way, but Haggard and Jones weren’t risking anything with their behavior. The Dixie Chicks, however, told their audience what they didn’t want to hear. Instead of flashing the “screw you” sign at New York, they flashed it at Tennessee.
They paid a steep professional price. Their last album, Taking the Long Way, was hardly a flop, but it sold significantly less than their previous records. It also never generated a hit on country radio. And when the band went on tour, they had to cancel Southern dates for lack of sales.
So again, the Chicks rejected the status quo of their community, and they paid a price. That’s rebellion.
My point here is not “the Chicks were right” and “country music was wrong.” It’s that most of the time, people don’t take a stand against the values of the groups that have accepted them, even if they disagree with those values. I would respect any artist who did that. I respect Cat Stevens, for instance, for going hardcore Islam, despite how it offended his liberal base.
Then again, because I agree with the Chicks, I’m especially taken with their actions. I find them inspiring because they stood up against behavior that offended me. When the world was watching, the used their art to take action.







14 responses so far ↓
1 Rachel // Sep 16, 2009 at 1:04 pm
OMG, I can’t believe that the song that began “New Song Monday” made it all the way to #2. I’m honored!! (and chilled to the bone, of course)
2 JOR3 // Sep 16, 2009 at 1:52 pm
Hey Mark – I enjoyed the list, had heard most of the artist but not all. I tend to lean more towards Brit-pop/Alt Rock but enjoyed your inclusion of a couple of alt country acts and Sugarland who I had never really listened to.
3 InfoMofo // Sep 16, 2009 at 1:53 pm
Awesome list- I definitely will check some of these songs I haven’t heard before.
2 Kanye songs? At this time? Risky.
Here are the songs I would have found a way to fit on if it were my list:
Amerie – 1 Thing
Ok, as catchy breaks go, you can’t beat this 10 second clip from The Meters’ 70s funk filler “Oh, Calcutta”. As a hip-hop artist Amerie tends to get lost in the field, but this song really showcases her fun, sexy voice.
Amy Winehouse – Rehab
Throwback songs can be dangerous, but this one works- this song instantly makes you think of the jangle of motown, only instead of Etta James, you have a Suicide Girl. It’s impossible not to recall Winehouse’s own run-ins with the media when you hear this song, but it’s that tired honesty that wins you over when you hear this song.
The Darkness – I Believe in a Thing Called Love
The Darkness broke out in 2004 and broke up in 2006, but in that short period of time they managed to resurrect male falsetto rock and glam. You can’t help but sing along with their screamy energetic vibe, and embarass yourself at karaoke.
The Ting Tings – That’s Not My Name
Shouty playground pop has always been popular, ever since Toni Basil’s Mickey, and continued through Gwen Stefani’s Hollaback Girl. The Ting Ting’s take that formula for their chorus, and pile on electronic beats and a droning background vocal underneath.
Evanescence – Bring Me To Life
It’s gothy, it’s emo, it has a piano. I’m pretty sure it’s about vampires. <3.
M.I.A. – Sunshowers
Or really any M.I.A. song. Obviously M.I.A. got a little overplayed in the aftermath of slumdogs, but she is still a dramatic artist who was just completely fresh. Despite not being able to understand a word she says due to being riddled by cockney slang and sri lankan, you still can get her message through the growl in her voice.
Other ones:
Corinne Bailey Rae – Put Your Records On
Some Lady Gaga, just cause
Ditto for Leona Lewis
4 Mark Blankenship // Sep 16, 2009 at 4:22 pm
@InfoMofo — No joke, if I had run this countdown up to 110 positions (which I considered), I would’ve included “I Believe in a Thing Called Love,” “10 Dollar” by M.I.A., “Rehab,” and “Bleeding Love.” Plus, I like all the other songs you mentioned. I hadn’t thought about Amerie in ages, so thanks for that flashback!
5 Mark Blankenship // Sep 16, 2009 at 4:23 pm
@Rachel — Honestly, Rachel, I don’t know what this countdown would look like if it weren’t for your influence. There’d be no “No Children” or Jens Lekman, and there’d be some half-ass analysis of “Crazy in Love” that missed the finer truths about the song.
6 Rube Goldberg // Sep 16, 2009 at 8:00 pm
I’m a little surprised that “My Love” by Justin Timberlake didn’t make your list. I truly believe that it is an example of the perfect pop song — catchy without being annoying, discussing a theme that just about everyone can identify with, and just enough sex appeal without approaching naughty.
Also, ditto everything on InfoMofo’s list. Would “Lip Gloss” fall into the 110 range?
7 Carley Brennan // Sep 16, 2009 at 9:09 pm
Mark, thanks so much for this terrific list. You introduced me to a lot of artists I hadn’t heard of before. Here’s a partial list of my discoveries thanks to you: Anberlin, Eric Hutchinson, Feist, Patty Griffin, Jens Lekman, Robyn, The Thermals, The Rasmus, Royksoop, Mindy Smith, The Streets, Elvis Perkins in Dearland, Miranda Lambert, and Sugarland.
Perhaps even more important, thanks for Dolly Parton’s “Turn, Turn, Turn.” That owns my soul, and I NEVER would have listened to it had it not been on the list.
iTunes also thanks you.
8 jam // Sep 17, 2009 at 8:31 am
I love your selection, but no Bloc Party? Because for me, the hard part would have been picking just one. The bitter-sweet nostalgia of I Still Remember (“you should have asked me for it, I would have been brave, you should have asked me for it, how could I say no?”), the way Hunting for Witches starts with that stuttering, staccato beginning before the heavily political vocals come in.
The build and then the killer pause before the instruments drop out on Song For Clay (Disappear Here), that krunked gregorian chant opening of The Prayer, the mixture of love and pain and something that’s not so much hope as waiting it out in Two More Years and Sunday…
The fact they sound like nothing else out there.
9 InfoMofo // Sep 17, 2009 at 10:59 am
@Rube- I was going to mention Lil Mama too! Although I would have voted for Shawty Get Loose. And then that whole VMA thing happened and I realized that 2 out of 3 people on that vocal team are now pariahs.
10 Mark Blankenship // Sep 17, 2009 at 11:18 am
I wrestled with the Lil Mama question, since “Lip Gloss” is so, so awesome. Definitely a worthy contender.
@Carley — I’m so glad this countdown introduced you to so many new artists and songs. Hearing that totally brightens my day!
11 Green // Sep 17, 2009 at 12:01 pm
I love that you love the Mountain Goats! I’ve probably run into you at one of the NYC shows, no? At the shows, screaming along to No Children and Best Ever Death Metal Band Out of Denton always makes me so happy, despite the nature of the lyrics…
12 InfoMofo // Sep 17, 2009 at 1:26 pm
When it’s Time for Lunch, My lips still RRRock. It’s Poppin’. I ain’t frontin’.
Aight I have to listen to that song again. My favorite part is with Ms McClarkson.
13 jessica // Sep 18, 2009 at 1:38 pm
I love, love, love, love, forever love The Dixie Chicks. Thanks for making them your number 1. (Their remake of Landslide is actually my sentimental favorite because it changed the way I felt about my life, but you’re right in every way about Not Ready to Make Nice.)
14 Casey // Sep 18, 2009 at 11:20 pm
Have you heard the Kiki and Herb cover of “No Children”? It’s brilliant.
Leave a Comment